Comment

Community comment are the opinions of contributing users. These comment do not represent the opinions of West Vancouver Memorial Library.
Nov 04, 2020YourLocalReader rated this title 3.5 out of 5 stars
The Downstairs Girls recounts Jo Kuan’s life as an Asian-American woman in Atlanta, Georgia, during the 1800s struggling to make a living. Jo secretly takes up a job to write for a popular newspaper advice column under the pseudonym Miss Sweetie; if anyone finds out, she will encounter scorn and disbelief. First off, I was attracted to this book because of the Asian representation, seen immediately from the cover. I found it utterly refreshing to finally witness a person who shares my race to be the main character without abiding by racial stereotypes. Jo has to be one of the most memorable characters I read: headstrong, unapologetic, smart, and relatable. She is not perfect, but that is one of the most endearing parts of her. There were so many elements incorporating immigrant and Asian lifestyles, making me so proud. The author also identifies as Asian-American making most parts of the story so personable compared to mere research. Some sections of this book made my blood boil towards Jo's unfair treatment. She faced so many racial and gender injustices without reason through racial slurs and jokes. I appreciate how the romance was a subplot to the story, while Jo's exploration of her personal and cultural identity was in the spotlight. Most of the time in novels, I find the main character shadowed by an overbearing romance. Some flaws I had regarded other characters and the overall pacing. While Jo was spotlighted, there were numerous interactions with other characters that intended to strengthen the plot, but the other characters were lackluster compared to Jo. I honestly think a few months from now, the only person I would remember is Jo, even if some of the characters had a large part in developing her identity. The pacing was a bit off; it was too fast. The ideas were brilliant, but the author rushed them. Some of the plot holes I could see coming, and the ending was rather abrupt. The conclusion broadcasted clear intentions; however, I wish there were a little more leading up to it. Overall, I would give it a fabulous 3.75 stars. The Asian representation was perfection; it captured the essence of what it means to struggle with your cultural identity in an accepting environment. I loved the main character so dearly; moreover, I could relate to her, so I am sure many others would be able to. Contrastingly, the lackluster side characters irked me. They seemed to be merely there without any impact; some of them were a little on the cliche side. The pacing threw me off; it just ended without much leading up to it. A delightful read that will enchant you to most likely finish it within a few days or hours while bringing awareness to the much needed immigrant story. Age recommendation: 12+, although labeled young adult fiction: I found it to be very mild in content. Some mentions of racial slurs( very minimal), mere hints of romance.